Nonprofit Executive Jobs & Leadership in Staten Island, NY – 2026 Guide
Executive Salaries • Search Firms • Richmond County Market Intelligence
Staten Island represents a distinct and tight-knit community within the broader New York City nonprofit ecosystem.
As we move into 2026, the “Borough of Parks” is seeing heightened demand for executive leaders who can navigate the unique challenges of Richmond County.
For additional mission-driven roles, explore the ExecSearches.com Non-profit Jobs Center.
2026 Staten Island Market Sentiment
The “Outer Borough” Funding Gap
Staten Island leaders often face the challenge of securing equitable funding compared to Manhattan-centric organizations. 2026 priorities include diversifying revenue streams.
Workforce Retention
Competition for talent is fierce. Organizations are offering flexible/hybrid work to attract talent from NJ and Brooklyn.
Recent Highlights
2026 Staten Island Executive Salary Benchmarks
| Role | 2026 Median |
|---|---|
| Executive Director / CEO | $150,000 – $210,000+ |
| Chief Operating Officer | $130,000 – $175,000+ |
| Chief Financial Officer | $155,000 – $190,000+ |
Why Recruit in Richmond County?
For executive search firms and HR departments, Staten Island offers a talent pool distinct from the rest of NYC. However, the “bridge toll barrier” requires competitive compensation packages.
💼 STATEN ISLAND LEADERSHIP SEARCH HUB
Regional Search Specialists
Scion Executive Search
Award-winning NYC-based firm with deep experience placing leadership across all five boroughs.
Isaacson, Miller
National search firm with a strong NYC practice, effective for higher education.
Last updated on January 15th, 2026 at 11:13 pm
0 Comments