[email protected]

Nonprofit Cover Letters

Write one. Plenty of employers never open it. The people who build the shortlist for a nonprofit executive search usually do, and they are reading for the one thing a resume cannot tell them: why this organization, and why now.

This section collects what our recruiters and career advisors have written about cover letters for nonprofit, association, foundation and public sector roles. Some of it goes back more than a decade. The advice has held up better than the technology around it.

Does anyone actually read it?

The published surveys disagree with each other, badly. Read four of them and you will find the share of employers who open a cover letter put anywhere from a third to nine in ten. Most of those studies are run by companies that sell resume products, and almost none separate corporate hiring from search work at a mission-driven organization.

Here is what we see from this side of the desk. The letter is rarely what gets you past the first screen, because the first screen is looking for a short list of qualifications and it is usually looking fast. The letter earns its keep later, when a search committee has eight finalists who all meet the specification and has to decide who to interview. At that point the resumes look alike and the letters do not.

For a board-facing role the letter matters more, not less. A board chair who has never hired a chief executive before will read every word of it.

What the letter has to do in a nonprofit search

Four things, and none of them is a summary of your resume.

Say why this organization. Name the work. If you are applying to a legal aid organization, say something about their eviction defense numbers or their rural offices. Generic admiration for the mission reads as a form letter, because it usually is one.

Match the scale. Nonprofit search turns on fit between what you have run and what they need run. An $8 million budget with 40 staff is a different job from a $90 million system with 600. Say which one you have done, in a number.

Name the hard thing. Most searches exist because something is difficult: a deficit, a merger, a founder leaving after 30 years, a program that has outgrown its building. If you can tell from the posting what that is, address it. Candidates who do this move to the top of the pile quickly.

Sound like a person. A letter that could have been written by anyone competent is worth almost nothing. The reader is trying to picture you in a room with their staff and their funders.

What to cut

Anything that repeats the resume in sentences. The word passionate, unless you follow it with evidence. Apologies for a gap or a career change, which draw attention to the thing you are apologizing for. And the second page. One page, every time.

Worth reading next

Start with Writing Persuasive Cover Letters. It is chapter 8 of Larry Slesinger’s book Search: Winning Strategies to Get Your Next Job in the Nonprofit World, and he gave us permission to republish it. Twenty years on it is still the best thing written on cover letters for our field. He opens from the recruiter’s chair, with the observation that most cover letters are weak and do nothing to advance the writer’s candidacy, then walks through what a strong one does instead. If you read one thing here, read that.

Do you need to write a cover letter to get the nonprofit dream job? is the fullest piece our own team has written on this. It covers what hiring teams are weighing when they open the letter and how to show fit without restating your history.

Does my application really need a cover letter? is the short version of the same argument, written for people who are deciding whether it is worth the hour.

Pain Letter: rethinking the cover letter approach takes a different line. Instead of opening with yourself, open with the problem the organization is trying to solve. It is the approach we recommend most often for people who have applied to a dozen roles and heard nothing.

Questions readers have sent us

Our career advisors have answered cover letter questions from job seekers for years, and those answers sit in this section alongside the articles above. They take on whether to submit a revised letter mid-process, what a search committee means when it asks for a thoughtful letter, and what to do when your letter sounds more driven than you are.

Where to go from here

Browse open roles on the ExecSearches job board, or start from the nonprofit career advice and salary guides for interviewing, salary ranges, negotiation and the guides to your own city or state.